Most of the comparisons, advantages, and disadvantages of Berber carpet on this website have been in relation to other carpets. So what about hardwood flooring? Hardwood flooring is a great flooring option in some instances. As a consumer, it is a good idea to at least familiarize yourself with hardwood before investing in flooring.
Advantages of Hardwood Flooring
Spill proof: One of the great advantages of Berber carpet is that spills soak up very easily, reducing carpet stains. This is an even greater advantage of hardwood flooring. Any spills can be mopped right up. It is virtually bullet proof to spills; one caveat is it is possible to ruin the finish of the hardwood, especially in less quality floors.
Durable: If taken care of appropriately, quality hardwood floors are very durable. Hardwoods don’t succumb to one of the major problems of cheap Berber carpet: crushing. Crushing is one of the major problems of cheap Berber carpet. Like the more expensive forms of Berber, you don’t have to worry much about hardwood flooring losing its visual appeal in high traffic areas.
Polished Look: Hardwood floors can have a very sophisticated look. They give character to certain rooms and can go with most types of furniture.
Disadvantages of Hardwood Flooring
Expense: After materials, labor, and everything else is all said and done, hardwood flooring is usually more expensive than any Berber carpet besides wool. The price per square foot is usually in the ballpark of nylon Berber carpet, but the costs for installation are greater. Like carpet, hardwood flooring prices vary drastically. This is just a very generalized estimate.
They’re hard: This sounds like a very generic reason, but it’s important to fully understand. A hard ground surface results in a noisier home. Sounds are reverberated off of the floor, rather than being absorbed like they are with carpet. Also, some people complain that cheaper Berber carpets are too hard to walk on. This is even truer with hardwood flooring, so make sure to give it a test walk before making a purchase.
Allergies: Hardwood flooring salesmen like to present it as a way to reduce allergies in one’s home. The theory presented is that carpets harbor dust and other allergens. This is correct, but it doesn’t tell the complete story. Think of it this way–either way these allergens are going to be somewhere in your home. With carpet, it is trapped. The carpet almost acts as a giant filter to be cleaned out with your vacuum and scheduled professional cleanings. Allergens can settle on hardwood flooring. As people walk on these floors, the allergens are kicked up and spread throughout the home.
The verdict of hardwood vs. Berber carpet
Both hardwood flooring and carpet have their place in a home. Hardwoods are great for entryways, kitchens and other areas that are exposed to a lot of oil traction and spills. Carpets are great for giving a soft walking surface, while insulating sound and temperature in your home. As far as appearance goes, mixing the two gives your home a great layered look. Having only one type of flooring throughout a home, especially hardwood, can give a home a dull look. This is true to some degree with carpet, but not quite as much, especially if different colors or patterns are utilized.